Suffern, NY - Bikur Cholim Fight Shutdown Of Shabbas House
Suffern, NY - A coalition of Orthodox Jewish groups cited federal law in seeking to keep open a residence for Jews visiting sick relatives in the hospital.
The National Jewish Commission on Law and Public Affairs filed a brief with the New York District Court in the case of Bikur Cholim vs. Village of Suffern, N.Y.
Suffern wants to shut down what has become known as the “Shabbas house” for zoning reasons. Orthodox Jews use the house as a residence while visiting relatives receiving treatment at the Good Samaritan Hospital across the street.
In the brief filed, the Jewish groups argued that closing the house would violate the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.
The National Jewish Commission on Law and Public Affairs filed a brief with the New York District Court in the case of Bikur Cholim vs. Village of Suffern, N.Y.
Suffern wants to shut down what has become known as the “Shabbas house” for zoning reasons. Orthodox Jews use the house as a residence while visiting relatives receiving treatment at the Good Samaritan Hospital across the street.
In the brief filed, the Jewish groups argued that closing the house would violate the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.
5 Comments:
At 12:45 AM, Anonymous said…
why is the Shabbos house any different than a Ronald McDonald house, which allows parents of sick patients to stay near their hospitalized children? It smacks of anti semitism.
At 9:55 AM, Anonymous said…
I agree strongly with the previous comment!!
At 5:21 PM, Anonymous said…
The Ronald McDonald house is supported by charitable contributions, not my tax dollars. Who pays for the Shabbas House?
At 12:02 AM, Anonymous said…
I'm sure the Shabbos house is not paid for by your tax dollars. It is probably paid for by Bikur Cholim, which is funded by charitable donations, not your tax dollars.Tax dollars is not the issue here.
At 9:14 PM, Anonymous said…
12:02 annon - I was just pointing out a possible difference between the two, McDonald house vs. Shabbos. I honestly wanted to know how it was funded/supported in order to come to a more educated opinion. And if you are correct, and the Shabbos is supported by charitable contributions, then I would have to agree with the first and second posts here: It would then smack of anti semitism. However, if it is funded by tax dollars (mine, yours, ours), then I might actually believe the "zoning reasons" statement.
Post a Comment
<< Home